Missionaries and Traders: Early Non-Native Influences on Hawaii

A quick note from the author: I chose to write about this issue due to the recent fires in Lahaina, and I have found that doing research for the issues that have been brought to light from that tragedy led me through so much information I felt it was easiest to start at the beginning, with Hawaii’s history. I have worked diligently to try and provide an accurate and thorough picture of all the information I am sharing. However, if any information is incorrect, don’t hesitate to contact me via email at jamie@flawedbydesignllc.com so I can make any needed corrections.

— —

Have you ever wondered how Hawaii transformed from an isolated archipelago to a melting pot of cultures and religions?

Before the arrival of missionaries and traders, Hawaii was a self-contained paradise, flourishing under its unique social, political, and religious systems. Governed by a kapu (taboo) system, this archipelago boasted a rich and complex tapestry of gods, chants, and rituals.

Understanding the early non-native influences of missionaries and traders is crucial for appreciating Hawaii’s cultural evolution and its current socio-political landscape. This article will delve into these early visitors’ significant impact, exploring their economic, religious, and cultural contributions while contrasting these influences to paint a comprehensive picture of Hawaii’s transformation.

Pre-Contact Hawaii

Indigenous Culture

Before the islands became a hub for international trade and a mission field for religious conversions, Hawaii had a rich and thriving indigenous culture. From the intricate hula dance to the profoundly emotional chants (oli), Hawaiians had a way of life uniquely intertwined with the land and sea. These practices were not mere entertainment but served as historical records, religious rites, and educational tools.

Social and Political Systems

The social and political structure was organized under a system known as the “ahupua’a,” a land division usually stretching from the mountains to the sea. This system enabled resource sharing and communal living, overseen by a chief or aliʻi. Society was hierarchical, with the kāhuna (priests or experts) and makaʻāinana (commoners) each having distinct roles — kapu laws regulated this societal structure, enforcing taboos and maintaining spiritual purity.

Religion and Spirituality

Spirituality was woven into the very fabric of daily life, with a pantheon of gods and goddesses governing various elements and activities. One of the principal deities was Pele, the goddess of fire and volcanoes, revered and feared for her power to create and destroy. Rituals, prayers, and offerings were an integral part of everyday living, aiming to maintain a balance between humans and the spiritual realm.

The Arrival of Traders

The Earliest Known Traders

Before Hawaii became a U.S. territory or even a kingdom of unified islands, it attracted traders worldwide. European explorers and American traders were among the first non-natives to engage in commerce with the Hawaiians, predominantly in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. The most lucrative and sought-after commodities were Sandalwood and whale oil, resources that were abundant in the archipelago.

Economic Impact

The influx of traders catalyzed a seismic shift in Hawaii’s economic landscape. Once revered for its spiritual significance, Sandalwood became a sought-after export, driving a commodity-based economy. Unfortunately, this led to over-harvesting and ecological consequences. Moreover, the newly introduced monetary system and trade imbalance contributed to the marginalization of native Hawaiians, disrupting the traditional ahupua’a system.

Cultural Exchange and Influence

Trade was not merely a one-way street; it facilitated a bilateral exchange of cultures. While Hawaiians were introduced to novel goods like metal tools and firearms, traders picked up aspects of indigenous culture, such as the hula dance and traditional chants. However, this exchange was not without its downsides. The introduction of foreign diseases like smallpox had devastating effects on the native population, forever altering the demographic makeup of the islands.

The arrival of traders was a pivotal event in Hawaii’s history, introducing opportunities and challenges. It paved the way for further interactions with the outside world and exposed native cultures to significant disruptions.

Case Study — The Sandalwood Trade

The sandalwood trade is an illustrative example of traders’ complex economic impact on Hawaii. Before Western contact, Sandalwood (ʻiliahi) was primarily used in traditional rituals and ceremonies. However, the arrival of traders transformed this sacred wood into a highly lucrative commodity.

Economic Benefits and Drawbacks

The immediate economic benefits were apparent. Sandalwood quickly became Hawaii’s first significant export, attracting traders and generating immense wealth for the ruling aliʻi. The newfound prosperity enabled them to gain access to foreign goods, such as weapons and textiles, thereby solidifying their political power.

However, the sandalwood trade had its drawbacks. Over-harvesting led to environmental degradation, causing long-term damage to native forests. Additionally, as the demand for labor increased, many native Hawaiians were pulled away from traditional agriculture, disrupting the self-sustaining ahupua’a system.

Long-term Consequences

The depletion of sandalwood stocks and the subsequent decline in trade led to economic instability. Combined with the challenges introduced by other forms of trade and contact, the Hawaiian economy was forced into a period of adjustment, eventually making way for different industries like sugar cane plantations to take root.

The Arrival of Missionaries

The First Missionaries and Their Objectives

The first documented missionaries to arrive in Hawaii were American Congregationalists in 1820, led by Hiram Bingham and Asa Thurston. Their primary objective was to spread Christianity and “civilize” the native Hawaiians. The missionaries viewed the indigenous religious practices as “pagan” and sought to replace them with Christian doctrines. While their intentions may have been rooted in spiritual conviction, the cultural ramifications were profound and often contentious.

Influence on Religion, Language, and Education

Religion

The most immediate and visible impact was on religion. The native religious system, with its myriad gods and goddesses, faced a fundamental transformation. Temples (heiau) were often abandoned or transformed into churches, and the kapu system significantly declined.

Language

To spread Christianity more effectively, missionaries developed a written form of the Hawaiian language, including creating the Hawaiian alphabet. This facilitated the translation of the Bible into Hawaiian but also served to document native oral traditions, thereby contributing to the preservation of some aspects of the culture.

Education

Missionaries also established some of Hawaii’s first schools for religious instruction and general education. These schools taught subjects such as reading, writing, and arithmetic alongside religious studies. However, the Western-centric curriculum often dismissed or devalued traditional practices.

The impact of missionaries on Hawaii is a subject of complex debate. While their arrival led to the introduction of Christianity and literacy, it also contributed to the erosion of native customs and beliefs.

Case Study — The Development of the Hawaiian Alphabet by Missionaries

The development of the Hawaiian alphabet is a striking example of the influence that missionaries wielded in Hawaii, especially on its language and education. Before missionary arrival, the Hawaiian language was solely oral. The conversion of this rich oral tradition into a written form had lasting positive and negative implications.

The Initial Effort

Missionaries led by Hiram Bingham and Asa Thurston undertook the formidable task of developing a written system for the Hawaiian language shortly after they arrived in 1820. Their primary motivation was to translate Christian scriptures and disseminate religious texts. Still, the ripple effect of this work went far beyond their initial intentions.

Simplification and Standardization

The first Hawaiian alphabet, consisting of 17 letters, was later simplified to 12 — five vowels and seven consonants. This streamlined alphabet made teaching Hawaiians how to read and write more accessible, accelerating literacy spread. However, this simplification also led to the loss of nuanced pronunciation in the original language.

Cultural Implications

While the written language facilitated the preservation of native stories and chants, it also served as a tool for cultural assimilation, especially regarding religious conversion and education. Furthermore, the introduction of a written system marked a shift from a culture that prioritized oral tradition to one that placed value on written records.

The development of the Hawaiian alphabet is a microcosm of missionary influence in Hawaii. It was a double-edged sword, offering both the preservation and erosion of native culture.

Cultural Shifts and Adaptations

Changes in Religious Practices

The introduction of Christianity by missionaries had a dramatic effect on native religious practices. Temples (heiau) and traditional gods and goddesses were increasingly sidelined in favor of Christian places of worship and doctrines. The kapu system, a set of religious laws and taboos, declined as Christian moral teachings gained prominence. The transformation was so profound that by the late 19th century, many Hawaiians had converted to Christianity.

Introduction of New Technologies and Skills

Traders and missionaries introduced various technologies and skills, from metal tools to Western-style shipbuilding. These innovations had a dual impact: they improved certain aspects of daily life. They led to the decline of indigenous technologies and craftsmanship. For instance, Western agricultural techniques led to increased productivity but also contributed to environmental degradation.

Socio-economic Changes

The arrival of traders and missionaries set in motion considerable socio-economic shifts. While the ahupua’a system once dictated land and resource distribution, the new economic conditions encouraged individual land ownership and capitalistic enterprise. This shift had both beneficial and detrimental effects: it created opportunities for economic growth but also led to economic disparities and the marginalization of native Hawaiians.

The early influences of traders and missionaries laid the groundwork for modern Hawaii but also created complexities that continue reverberating in Hawaiian culture and society today.

Contrast and Comparison: Traders vs. Missionaries

The Differing Influences of Traders and Missionaries

Though traders and missionaries arrived in Hawaii with objectives that often intersected, their influences took different paths.

Traders: Primarily driven by economic gains, traders sought commodities like Sandalwood and whale oil. Their influence was mainly materialistic, changing the economic fabric of Hawaii but rarely imposing ideological or cultural changes.

Missionaries: On the other hand, their arrival was motivated by a desire for spiritual conversion and cultural assimilation. They impacted not just religious practices but also education and social norms.

The Integration and Erosion of Native Practices

Integration: Both traders and missionaries contributed to integrating new technologies, skills, and beliefs into Hawaiian society. Native Hawaiians adopted metal tools, new agricultural techniques, and even elements of Christianity, merging them with their traditional ways of life.

Erosion: Conversely, the introduction of foreign religions, languages, and economic systems led to the deterioration of native practices. The kapu system and traditional religious beliefs saw significant declines, as did the ahupua’a land management system.

The influences of traders and missionaries were both constructive and disruptive, shaping modern Hawaii in ways still being assessed and understood today.

Summary of Long-Term Effects

The early influences of traders and missionaries have had a lasting impact on Hawaii, profoundly shaping its religious, cultural, and socio-economic landscape. Traders introduced new commodities and technologies, fostering economic changes and influencing Hawaii today. Missionaries altered the core of Hawaiian religious and social practices through their spiritual and educational endeavors. The effects are not merely historical footnotes but active influences that continue to reverberate in contemporary Hawaiian society.

The Current State of Hawaii Concerning Its Early History

Modern Hawaii is a complex tapestry woven from both native and introduced threads. Its current religious diversity, advanced educational systems, and bustling economic activities can all trace their roots back to these early non-native influences. However, the erosion of native practices and techniques has also led to a concerted effort to revive and preserve Hawaiian culture. From the resurgence of the Hawaiian language to the rekindling of traditional navigation and agricultural practices, Hawaii today is engaged in a delicate dance between preservation and modernization.

The arrival of traders and missionaries is a critical juncture in Hawaiian history, from which numerous lines of development radiate. Understanding these early influences allows us to appreciate the multifaceted nature of Hawaii today. It offers a blueprint for navigating its complex future.

Additional Resources

The following resources are highly recommended for those interested in diving deeper into Hawaii’s fascinating history and culture.

Recommended Readings

1. “Hawaii’s Story by Hawaii’s Queen” by Queen Liliuokalani: This book offers a native perspective on Hawaiian history. Available here
2. “Shoal of Time: A History of the Hawaiian Islands” by Gavan Daws: A comprehensive history of Hawaii, covering various aspects from its earliest days to modern times. Available here

*I do not receive any commission if you purchase the above-listed resources.

Documentaries

1. “Hawaii’s Last Queen”: A PBS documentary focusing on Queen Liliuokalani and the overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom. Watch here
2. “Act of War: The Overthrow of the Hawaiian Nation”: This documentary covers the 1893 overthrow of the Hawaiian Kingdom. Watch here

Podcasts

1. “Hawaiian History and Culture”: This podcast series delves into various aspects of Hawaii, from its history to its modern-day challenges. Listen here
2. “Offshore”: A podcast exploring stories from Hawaii that go beyond the typical tourist narrative. Listen here

Websites

1. Hawaii State Archives: A treasure trove of historical documents and photographs. Visit here
2. The Polynesian Voyaging Society: An organization dedicated to preserving traditional Polynesian navigation methods. Visit here

Sources

Ariyoshi, George R. Hawai’i’s Future. Honolulu: Legacy Isle Publishing, 2020.

Chen, Loretta. Inspiring Women of Hawaii. Honolulu: Mutual Publishing, 2019.

Davidson, Janet M. The Cook Voyages Encounters: The Cook Voyages Collections of Te Papa. Wellington, New Zealand: Te Papa Press, 2019.

Goodsill, Jane Marshall. Voices of Hawaii: Life Stories from the Generation that Shaped the Aloha State. Honolulu: Watermark, 2019.

Langlas, Charles and Jeffrey Lyon, eds. The Mo’olelo Hawaii of Davida Malo. Volume 2: Hawaiian Text and Translation. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 2020.

Lincon, Noa Kekuewa. Ko: An Ethnobotanical Guide to Hawaiian Sugarcane Cultivars. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 2020.

Schutz, Albert J. Hawaiian Language: Past, Present, Future. Honolulu: University of Hawai’i Press, 2020.

Rice, Stian. “The Hawaiian Sandalwood Famines: 1820s.” In Famine in the Remaking: Food System Change and Mass Starvation in Hawaii, Madagascar, and Cambodia, 13–78. Morgantown: West Virginia University Press, 2020.

Siegel, Jeff. “Contact Languages of the Pacific.” In Handbook of Language Contact, edited by Raymond Hickey, 741–762. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley-Blackwell, 2020.

About the Author

Jamie Hairston, M.S. (Christian Counseling of Substance Abuse and Addictive Disorders)

Jamie is a former addiction counselor who now writes fiction about substance abuse and mental health issues. She has authored two short novels in her Memoirs of a Black Sheep series and a series she co-authors, The Borderline Chronicles, on Amazon Kindle Vella. Jamie has also formed her own small publishing company, Flawed By Design Publishing LLC, where she produces her published works and offers other writing and media services.

Flawed by Design is a woman-owned, veteran-owned business for those who seek a writing coach, editor, or proofreader.